7 Items You Should Always Buy Generic

A woman compares prices of groceries in a notebook while shopping at a discount supermarket.

6. Common Dairy Products (Milk, Butter, Plain Yogurt)

For basic dairy items like plain milk (whole, 2%, skim), unsalted or salted butter, and plain unflavored yogurt, store brands are often produced in the same dairies or to the same standards as the name brands. The primary difference is usually the label and the price.

Why generic is a smart buy: Milk is milk, and butter is butter. These are highly regulated products. Unless you have a very specific preference for the taste of a particular artisanal butter or a specialty organic milk brand (which is a different consideration), the store brand will likely serve you just as well for your morning coffee, baking, or spreading on toast, but at a lower cost. The savings on these frequently purchased items can be quite consistent.

What to look for: Check expiration dates, just as you would with any dairy product. For yogurt, if you prefer flavored varieties, you might be more brand-loyal, but for plain yogurt used in cooking or as a base for your own additions, generic is a great choice.

Check out this post on:  Dollar Stores Aren’t for Emergencies Anymore — They’re a Budget Strategy
< 1 ... 34 5 6>
Picture of Emily Johnson

Emily Johnson

Emily is a Midwest mom of three with a passion for stretching every dollar. With over a decade of experience managing household finances on a single income, she shares real-world budgeting tips, family savings strategies, and financial advice that actually works in everyday life.
Picture of Emily Johnson

Emily Johnson

Emily is a Midwest mom of three with a passion for stretching every dollar. With over a decade of experience managing household finances on a single income, she shares real-world budgeting tips, family savings strategies, and financial advice that actually works in everyday life.

2 Responses

  1. I have to disagree with the idea that all flour is created equal. Some generic lour isn’t even good enough to make play dough. Sticking with name brand flour such as Pillsbury or Gold Medal is best for baking. If you want to splurge then you can use King Arthur. If you need specialty flours then Bob’s Red Mill.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

top picks

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get weekly money tips straight to your inbox!

You’ll learn how to:

Enter your email below to join the community.

you may also like

what keeps you poor

Money Habits That Keep People Poor

Not because they’re lazy or careless—but because these habits quietly block progress over time Talking about “money habits that keep people poor” can feel uncomfortable. Too often, this topic is

Read More
overspend

Why You Overspend (And How to Stop)

A realistic look at the emotional, psychological, and practical reasons behind overspending—and what actually works in real life Overspending is often framed as a discipline problem. “Just stop buying things

Read More

How to Budget When Money Is Tight

A realistic guide to staying afloat, reducing stress, and slowly regaining control When money is tight, traditional budgeting advice can feel insulting.“Save 20%.”“Cut back on lattes.”“Just earn more.” But what

Read More
Stay Smart with Your Money!

Follow American Pockets on social media for bite-sized money tips and real-life finance hacks!

What you’ll get:

Follow us now — your wallet will thank you!