But… Does It Actually Make Financial Sense?
Here’s where the “sort of” part comes in.
Experts agree that while the 100 Envelopes Challenge is a great starter habit, it’s not the best long-term strategy. Why? Because keeping cash at home has a few major downsides:
-
It loses value over time. Inflation slowly eats away at your money’s purchasing power.
-
It earns zero interest. That same $5,050 could make you extra cash sitting in a high-yield savings account instead of your nightstand.
-
It’s not the safest. Unless you’re storing it in a fireproof safe, you’re one spilled coffee or one curious pet away from a financial meltdown.
That said — experts aren’t dismissing it. They’re saying: use it as a launchpad, not a landing zone.
Once you finish the challenge, you can deposit your envelopes into a high-yield savings account or even invest part of it. That way, the emotional reward of saving stays intact, but your money also starts working for you.
The Real Lesson Behind the Trend
So why does this trend stick when others fade? Because it hits the sweet spot between psychology, aesthetics, and accountability.
It’s not just a savings plan — it’s a mini vision board. You see your progress. You touch it. You feel it.
And that tactile connection matters more than you’d think. For people who grew up in a digital world where money moves invisibly, the physical act of saving cash feels grounding. It’s a reminder that you own what you’re building.
It’s also deeply human. We like rituals. We like stories. We like the feeling of being part of a collective experiment. When you post that “envelope 27 done!” TikTok, you’re joining thousands of others chasing the same little victory.
